It's
rare that I can go through a day
here at Sound Beach Music without
receiving one of these string
related questions: "Why can't I put
nylon strings on my steel string
guitar?", or "What do you mean
'string gauge?'".
Well friends, in this month's
installment of How/Why, I'll be
answering all these burning
questions and more.
Chapter One: If Nylon is
fine on a classical, then steel is
the deal to get the right feel...
Hey, I never claimed to be a
poet. Here's the deal, guys. It all
comes down to tension. And no, I'm
not talking about the weird tension
at the table after your holiday
dinner when Uncle Jack had a little
too much to drink. I'm talking about
string tension.
When a guitar is tuned to
standard tuning (EADGBe), there is a
certain amount of tension exerted on
the neck. If you look at a tuned
guitar neck, it should be straight.
If you removed the string tension,
the neck will bend backwards. This
is because a guitar neck is designed
to have a certain amount of tension
exerted on it at all times.
Now, let's look at materials.
Classical strings, or nylon strings
will exert substantially less
tension on the neck of the
instrument. Steel, because of the
tensile strength of the material
itself, will exert substantially
more tension on the neck. This is
why these strings are not
interchangeable. Nylon strings on a
steel string guitar will not bring
the neck straight, and steel strings
on a nylon string guitar will pull
the neck too far forward. Both lead
to an instrument that is not
playable. And worst of all, doing
this could permanently warp your
guitar's neck. No bueno.
Chapter Two: Electric
Guitar String Gauge
This is possibly the most
frequently asked question by new
players. "What is a 'string gauge?'"
It's not as complicated as it
sounds.
Let's say you came in to our
store and bought your first guitar.
It's an electric guitar from Ibanez,
or maybe a Starcaster. From the
factory, that guitar had 9-gauge
strings. 9's are considered "extra
light." These are frequently used by
rock players and those who live to
solo. They bend easier and are light
on your fingers. The next step up is
10-gauge.
10's are used by players from all
genres. It's a personal preference,
but it's generally accepted that
your tone will be better as you move
up to a heavier string. 10's are
harder on the fingers and won't bend
as easily, which some players like.
It's a matter of control really, and
you'll have more of it with this
gauge string.
11 and 12 gauge strings are
typically reserved for two types of
players. Either those who are
playing jazz music and demand the
best possible tone, or the metal
heads who drop tune down to C or
lower. This is really for more
advanced players and by the time you
know enough to play these styles of
music, you'll know a whole lot about
strings.
Chapter Three: Acoustic
Guitar String Gauges
"There's a difference?" Of COURSE
there's a difference! It's never
that easy!
Acoustic guitars typically
utilize a heavier string. This is
for tonal purposes as well as
volume. Light gauge strings on an
acoustic are 12 gauge. This is most
likely what came on your instrument
from the factory. Up from there, we
have 13 gauge strings. People choose
these for the tonal properties they
exhibit, as well as the feel. Some
people just prefer a heavier string.
Heavier
strings are available, but are very
uncommon.
Now, down from the 12 gauge
strings are your 11 gauges. These
are easier on the fingers and are
frequently used by those who do a
lot of playing on an
acoustic/electric guitar. These are
the "9 gauges" of the acoustic
world.
Chapter Four: Know your
onion
materials
It seems like strings can be made
of anything these days. We've got
colored strings, coated strings, and
strings that glow in the dark.
Nickel, steel, bronze, and what the
heck is "phosphor bronze?" String
material comes down to a couple of
features. Tone, playability, and
life span. On an acoustic guitar,
the strings will have a more drastic
effect on tone than on an electric.
Electric guitar strings are more
about feel and longevity, but that's
not to say that it won't still
affect your tone. Recently, some
companies have taken to using
different colored coatings on
strings to spice things up a bit.
These not only look cool, but will
increase the life of your string.
However, some players will argue
that this impacts how a string
feels. This is really an issue of
personal preference though, as is
the differentiation between nickel
wound and steel wound strings. Your
best bet is to go with what you know
at first and to explore once you
become a more proficient player.
Now, acoustic guitars are an
entirely different game. Phosphor
bronze is regular bronze's warmer
cousin. Phosphor bronze is an alloy,
and is not only tonally different
from regular bronze, but it lasts
longer due to the addition of
phosphorous, a deoxidizing agent,
during the melting process. Now, an
option in extending a strings life
span is moving on to a coated
string. There are pros and cons to
making this move, however. While the
string will last substantially
longer, many believe that the
coating will deaden the tone of the
string a bit. At this point, it's a
personal preference. There is a
seemingly endless array of coated
strings all claiming to have better
tone than the next. Your best bet is
to try a bunch over the course of
your playing career and pick for
yourself.